Old Town Cheese

Our Story

The Heart of Old Town Cheese

In the heart of Negaunee lies Old Town, a place rich with history and personal significance for us. Old Town Cheese is more than just a store; it’s a tribute to a cherished part of our lives and a celebration of fine, artisanal foods.

The Beginning

A Love Story and a Shared Passion

Our story begins over 20 years ago, when we, Kelsi and Michael, met in high school. Our bond grew stronger over the years, nurtured by shared adventures and a mutual love for good food. One of our favorite pastimes was sneaking into the fenced-off area of Old Town, a section of the city that was slowly closed off over the course of several decades due to mining and unstable ground. Among the abandoned foundations and overgrown paths, we found a special place that became a cornerstone of our relationship.

Tribute

A Tribute to Old Town

Old Town holds a deep personal significance for us. Kelsi’s relatives lived and went to school there before it was closed, adding another layer of connection. When Old Town was reopened and transformed into a beautiful park several years ago, it became a symbol of renewal and community for us and for the city.

Our Business

Crafting Community and Flavor

With Old Town Cheese, we aim to bring the same sense of discovery and joy to our customers. Our store offers an array of specialty cheeses, charcuterie, wine, and all the perfect pairings that elevate the experience of fine dining at home. We also serve delicious grilled cheese sandwiches, crafted with the same artisanal care that goes into all our products.

Behind the Scenes

A Family Effort

Kelsi, the heart and soul of Old Town Cheese, runs the day-to-day operations, bringing her passion and expertise to every aspect of the business. Michael offers support from behind the scenes, handling logistics and ensuring everything runs smoothly. Together, we bring over two decades of partnership and dedication to our venture.

Legacy

Building a Legacy

Our journey from those secretive explorations in Old Town to opening our own store has been one filled with love, passion, and a deep commitment to quality. We source our products from trusted local and international artisans, ensuring that each item we offer meets our high standards.

Hub

A Community Hub

Old Town Cheese is not just a store; it’s a community hub where locals and tourists alike can gather, explore, and enjoy the finest cheeses, charcuterie, and wines. We are proud to be a part of Old Town’s revival and to contribute to its legacy of bringing people together.

Future

Looking to the Future

As we look to the future, we are excited to grow and continue sharing our love for fine foods with our community. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick sandwich, selecting the perfect cheese for a special occasion, or simply enjoying a glass of wine with friends, we invite you to be a part of our story.

Join us at Old Town Cheese, where every visit is a journey through history, flavor, and family.